Should our firm move to passwordless sign-in and passkeys?
Short answer: yes — because passwords are still one of the biggest sources of cyber risk in your firm. Most security breaches still start with compromised logins. Passkeys and passwordless sign-in remove that risk altogether. For CFOs and COOs, this isn’t technical — it’s a practical way to reduce exposure, strengthen controls, and stay aligned with current guidance — particularly as the UK’s National Cyber Security Centre now recommends moving away from passwords. A typical transition takes 12 to 18 months for a mid-market firm. The real question is not if you move, but how quickly you get there safely.
Why passwords were always the weak link
Passwords are a 1960s invention. They were designed for a world where a small number of trusted users shared time on a single mainframe – not for the modern reality of every employee holding hundreds of online accounts across cloud services, deal rooms, fund administration portals and SaaS tools. Almost every aspect of the password – its length, its complexity rules, the need to rotate it, the impossibility of remembering dozens of unique ones – is a workaround for a fundamentally fragile design.
The result is predictable. Users reuse passwords. They write them down. They fall for phishing pages that are pixel-perfect copies of Microsoft 365 or their administrator’s portal. And as multi-factor authentication has become standard, attackers have moved on – using phishing-as-a-service kits to steal session tokens and pushing MFA fatigue prompts until a tired user taps approve.
You cannot leak a credential that does not exist
This is the most important point for any CFO or COO weighing the case. The overwhelming majority of cyber incidents in our sector start with stolen or leaked user credentials. If the credential never existed in the first place – because the user never knew it, never typed it, and never shared it – it cannot be phished, harvested by malware, or pasted into a fake login page.
That is exactly what passkeys deliver. Passwordless authentication for financial services firms removes the single artefact that attackers depend on. It is a step-change in cyber resilience, not a marginal improvement.
What passkeys actually are, in plain English
A passkey is a cryptographic credential bound to a device. When you sign in, your device proves to the service that it holds the right key – without ever sending a secret over the network or asking you to remember anything. Approving a sign-in is the same gesture you already use to unlock your phone: a fingerprint, a face scan, or a PIN.
There is nothing for a user to forget, nothing to mistype, and nothing to phish.
The NCSC has formally moved the line
In April 2026, the NCSC published “Leave passwords in the past – passkeys are the future”, formally recommending passkeys as the default authentication method – a reversal of decades of guidance. Their accompanying technical paper concluded that passkeys are at least as secure as, and generally more secure than, the strongest password paired with two-step verification.
For regulated firms, this matters beyond the headline. The NCSC’s position now sits behind any conversation with the FCA, your cyber insurer, or a due-diligence team about whether your authentication controls are proportionate but defensible.
Windows Hello for Business – two real factors, finally
For staff on managed Windows devices, the foundation is already in place. Windows Hello for Business pairs the device’s TPM chip (something you have) with a biometric or PIN (something you are or know). Crucially, the biometric never leaves the device – it unlocks the local key, which the TPM uses to sign the authentication challenge.
This is genuine multi-factor authentication, built into the operating system, with no SMS code to intercept and no push notification to spam.
Microsoft’s enterprise direction is now passkey-first
Microsoft’s roadmap reinforces the same direction. Passkey sign-in via Microsoft Authenticator and Windows Hello has been generally available in Entra ID for some time, and Microsoft has now confirmed that Edge will roll out passkey synchronisation for enterprise users from June 2026. In practical terms: no extra hardware, no separate FIDO2 keys to provision, and a path that uses the Authenticator app already on most users’ phones.
Adopt passkeys in the workplace without buying tokens
Many firms still associate passwordless with handing every employee a hardware security key. That model worked, but it is no longer the modern default. The Authenticator app on a managed mobile phone now plays the same role for the vast majority of users – and for partners and senior staff who want belt-and-braces, hardware FIDO2 keys remain available as a backup.
A realistic 12 to 18 month roadmap
The pragmatic shape of a programme looks like this. Begin by enrolling passkeys alongside existing passwords for your highest-risk users – partners, finance, IT admins. Expand to the full firm over the following quarter. Identify line-of-business apps that do not yet support FIDO2 and put plans in place – usually federation through Entra ID. Then, once coverage is high enough, switch the default authentication method, disable password sign-in by exception, and finally remove stored passwords entirely.
Twelve to eighteen months is realistic for most mid-market firms. Rushing it creates lockouts; delaying it leaves the weakest control in your stack untouched.
Passwordless and passkeys – the bottom line
Passkeys vs passwords for business is no longer a finely balanced debate. Passwords were always a workaround for a problem cryptography can now solve properly. The NCSC has said so, Microsoft has built it into the platform you are already paying for, and the threat landscape leaves little room to defer the decision. The right question for a regulated firm is not whether to adopt passwordless – it is how quickly you can get there safely.
How we can help
At Doherty Associates, we’ve spent over 34 years helping organisations in highly regulated, risk-sensitive industries strengthen their cyber resilience – with identity and access modernisation now forming a core part of that mission.
Whether you’re looking to plan a passwordless rollout, validate the readiness of your Microsoft 365 environment, or run a phased programme to retire passwords across your firm, our team can act as an extension of your internal IT and security function.
If you’re exploring how passkeys and passwordless authentication could reduce risk and strengthen your firm’s identity posture, our specialists would be happy to guide you through the best next steps. Learn more on our Managed Cyber Security Services page.
We’re here to help
If you want to achieve better outcomes for your business through a more intelligent use of technology, talk to us.
Contact us